
Your rating
Your collection and ratings are saved in this browser and shown in My Dream Theater.
- Released (United States)
- 27 Oct 2009
- Label
- InsideOut Music
- Formats
- CD, DVD, 12" Vinyl, Digital Media
- Producers
- Transatlantic
- Written
- April 2009
- Recorded
- 2009
- Recording studios
- Neal Morse’s studio, Tennessee
Side projects · Transatlantic · 2009
The Whirlwind
✎ Edit this releaseTracklist
CD 1: The Whirlwind
- The Whirlwind : Overture / Whirlwind9:53
- The Whirlwind : The Wind Blew Them All Away6:09
- The Whirlwind : On the Prowl6:02
- The Whirlwind : A Man Can Feel6:35
- The Whirlwind : Out of the Night4:22
- The Whirlwind : Rose Colored Glasses7:53
- The Whirlwind : Evermore4:10
- The Whirlwind : Set Us Free5:03
- The Whirlwind : Lay Down Your Life5:10
- The Whirlwind : Pieces of Heaven2:17
- The Whirlwind : Is It Really Happening?8:11
- The Whirlwind : Dancing with Eternal Glory / Whirlwind (Reprise)12:03
CD 2: Bonus originals and covers
- Spinning9:58
- Lenny Johnson4:20
- For Such a Time5:22
- Lending a Hand8:43
- The Return of the Giant Hogweed (Genesis cover)8:26
- A Salty Dog (Procol Harum cover)4:59
- I Need You4:39I Need You · I Need You
- Soul Sacrifice (Santana cover)8:38
DVD: Making of The Whirlwind (deluxe edition)
- Making of The Whirlwind · Documentary; approximately 105 minutes.105:00
Personnel
Transatlantic
- Neal Morse – Keyboards; acoustic guitar; vocals
- Roine Stolt – Electric and acoustic guitars; keyboards; vocals
- Pete Trewavas – Bass; vocals
- Mike Portnoy – Drums; vocals
Guest musicians
- Chris Carmichael – Strings
- Marc Papeghin – French horn
Production
- Jerry Guidroz – Engineering
- Rich Mouser – Mixing
- Robert Vosgien – Mastering
The Whirlwind is an unusually literal return to the idea of an album as one complete piece. Its twelve CD indexes give the listener useful landmarks, but they belong to a continuous composition lasting more than seventy minutes. The opening themes, shorter changes of atmosphere and large closing section all have a place within that larger movement. Hearing an individual section tells only part of the story.12
Transatlantic reunited in April 2009 after an eight-year gap between studio albums. Portnoy’s contemporary comments in Through My Words are refreshingly practical about how the music was made. The band spent ten days at Morse’s studio, arranging a section and recording it before moving to the next. Those recordings gave them something to revisit as the structure developed, and eventually provided the basis for a click track and Portnoy’s finished drums.34
That method helps explain the balance between the album’s scale and the character of its smaller sections. “Rose Colored Glasses” has room for a vocal melody to settle, while “Pieces of Heaven” is a much shorter instrumental passage. “Is It Really Happening?” works through a more insistent idea before “Dancing with Eternal Glory” brings the music towards its final return. The changes matter because the listener has travelled through the rest of the piece to reach them.12
Portnoy described the musical chemistry as returning immediately. The band did not spend the reunion trying to work out whether it could still function; the writing itself answered that question. The result also develops an idea already present on Bridge Across Forever, where recurring themes linked separate songs. Here, the connections belong to one composition from the outset.3
The second disc is a separate collection, with four originals followed by four covers. Stolt’s “Lenny Johnson”, Morse and Trewavas’s “For Such a Time”, and Trewavas’s “Lending a Hand” retain their individual writing credits. Genesis, Procol Harum and Santana are represented among the covers, while “I Need You” combines the America and Beatles songs of that name. The main album’s unity should not obscure the more varied purpose of this supplementary material.12
The deluxe edition adds a third disc, a making-of DVD running for approximately 105 minutes. It documents the work behind the finished album rather than adding another audio version of the composition.5
Released in October 2009, The Whirlwind led to a tour built around performing the complete piece. Its later live recordings make that continuity especially clear. The twelve movements remain useful reference points, but the work itself is The Whirlwind, whether presented as twelve studio tracks or one extended concert performance.12
Footnotes
-
Official special edition and its separate bonus disc. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Original album indexing, bonus composition credits and personnel. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Portnoy on the reunion sessions, New Voice 11/12, 2009, Through My Words. ↩ ↩2
-
Portnoy on returning after eight years, Classic Rock Society, 2009, Through My Words. ↩


