
Your rating
Your collection and ratings are saved in this browser and shown in My Dream Theater.
- Released (Japan)
- 25 Jul 2002
- Released (Magna Carta)
- 10 Sept 2002
- Label
- Magna Carta
- Catalog number
- MAR-02749 (Japan); MA-0911-2 (Magna Carta)
- Formats
- CD, Digital Media
- Recorded
- September-October 2001
- Recording studios
- Helen Hayes Performing Arts Center, Nyack, New York (September 24, 2001 concert)Jordan Rudess home studio (subsequent improvisations)
Solo albums · Jordan Rudess · 2002
4NYC
✎ Edit this releaseTracklist
- My Thoughts02:12
- If I Could07:08
- A Step Beyond04:13
- Outcast04:25
- Lamb Chops02:40
- Within05:32
- One Voice03:50
- Real Time03:25
- Mourning After06:05
- Darkness To Day05:44
- Speed As Light03:35
- On My World05:57
- For You05:45
Personnel
Personnel
- Jordan Rudess – Steinway grand piano, Kurzweil K2600, Korg Karma
4NYC began with a concert organised in the aftermath of September 11, 2001. On September 24, Jordan Rudess performed at the Helen Hayes Performing Arts Center in Nyack, New York, raising money for the American Red Cross. The album combines material from that evening with improvisations recorded at home during the following week. It is therefore neither a complete concert document nor a wholly separate studio record.1
Magna Carta released it on September 10, 2002. Both Rudess and the label committed part of the proceeds to charitable organisations in memory of those killed in the attacks. The recording’s circumstances belong to its history, rather than being an interpretation attached later because of the title.1
A concert without a fixed program
Rudess described going onstage without knowing exactly what he would play. He used a nine-foot Steinway alongside a Kurzweil K2600 and a Korg Karma, allowing the performance to move between piano and electronic sounds. Danielle Rudess produced the event, with the show assembled quickly through friends, the Red Cross and his online community.1
The full evening included Dream Theater and Liquid Tension Experiment material, as well as “Mary Had a Little Lamb” requested by his daughter. When he reviewed the recording, Rudess preferred the improvised passages, but there was not enough of that material for an album. He spent the next week recording further improvisations and built 4NYC from the two sources.1
That distinction explains why the release should not be presented as a set list of everything played at the benefit. The album is a selection shaped after the event. The studio work continued the musical response rather than attempting to reconstruct the concert in its entirety.
The record that resulted
“My Thoughts” opens the thirteen-track program, followed by “If I Could”, “A Step Beyond”, “Outcast” and “Lamb Chops”. The sequence continues through “Within”, “One Voice”, “Real Time”, “Mourning After” and “Darkness to Day”, before “Speed as Light”, “On My World” and “For You”. The changing track lengths give the album a varied pace without the proportions of a single extended suite.2
There is something appropriate about an improvisational approach here. A response to an event of this scale did not necessarily need a carefully announced concept and a story to be followed. The act of playing for other people, and then retaining the performances that seemed to communicate something, supplied the reason for the record.
Piano and technology together
The instrument list also prevents a misleading shortcut. Rudess did not make every reflective record on acoustic piano alone. At this concert, the synthesizers and the Steinway were part of the same musical setting. What matters is the use of each sound, not whether one can be placed on the respectable side of a supposed divide between acoustic feeling and electronic display.
4NYC preserves a particular response to a particular moment. Its mixture of live and studio improvisations is central to that identity, and more informative than treating it as another numbered stop between the larger prog albums.
The Japanese Marquee CD preceded the September Magna Carta edition, appearing on July 25, 2002.3


