Planet X cover

Your rating

Your collection and ratings are saved in this browser and shown in My Dream Theater.

Released
13 Jul 1999
Label
Magna Carta
Formats
CD, Digital Media
Producers
Derek Sherinian
Recording studios
The Leopard Room

Solo albums · Derek Sherinian · 1999

Planet X

Official clips

Tracklist

  1. Atlantis : Part 1: Apocalypse 1470 B.C.06:59
  2. Atlantis : Part 2: Sea of Antiquity04:18
  3. Atlantis : Part 3: Lost Island05:38
  4. Crab Nebulae04:07
  5. Box05:05
  6. Money Shot04:26
  7. Day in the Sun04:58
  8. State of Delirium02:48
  9. Space Martini03:47
  10. Brunei Babylon05:39

Personnel

Personnel

  • Derek Sherinian – Keyboards
  • Virgil Donati – Drums
  • Tony Franklin – Bass
  • Brett Garsed – Guitar

Planet X began as Derek Sherinian’s solo album while he was still in Dream Theater. By the time it was finished, he was out of the band, and the record had supplied both a sound and a name for his next one. There are more comfortable ways to start a solo career. There are probably less productive ones too.1

Magna Carta released the album in 1999. Sherinian played keyboards, Virgil Donati drums, Tony Franklin bass and Brett Garsed guitar. This is the quartet on the original recording, before Tony MacAlpine joined the band subsequently called Planet X.2

Building the Leopard Room

In his retrospective account, Sherinian traced the project to an approach from Magna Carta’s Peter Morticelli. Mike Varney suggested Donati, and their first writing session produced the opening part of the “Atlantis” suite. Around two months of work supplied the album. Franklin came from a recent session acquaintance, while Donati brought in fellow Australian Garsed.1

Varney also encouraged Sherinian to invest in a home ADAT setup. Drums were recorded to two-inch tape and transferred for overdubbing at the Leopard Room. Sherinian remembered receiving Dream Theater’s dismissal call on his first day of keyboard overdubs. The album was already underway; it was not an angry response composed after the split.1

That distinction matters when listening to it. This is an existing interest being given room to expand, rather than a keyboard player trying to prove that his former band had underestimated the number of notes he could play.

Atlantis, then somewhere stranger

The first three tracks form “Atlantis”: “Apocalypse 1470 B.C.”, “Sea of Antiquity” and “Lost Island”. Together they occupy roughly seventeen minutes. They establish the record’s scale immediately, with the keyboard and drum relationship carrying considerably more weight than an ordinary soloist-and-accompaniment arrangement would suggest.2

Donati is central to that identity. With this much rhythmic information, the music can feel as though several parts are trying to pull the floor in different directions. Garsed’s fluid phrasing supplies another line through it, and Franklin’s fretless bass gives the quartet a different texture from the later MacAlpine-fronted guitar configuration.

After the suite, “Crab Nebulae”, “Box”, “Money Shot”, “Day in the Sun”, “State of Delirium”, “Space Martini” and “Brunei Babylon” give the quartet a series of shorter settings. The changes of scale help the album move beyond the imposing opening.2

An album that became a band

Sherinian and Donati continued the partnership with MacAlpine, using Planet X as their group name. The solo album had supplied the basis for a working band, but Garsed’s playing gives this first recording a character of its own.13

It is also a useful corrective to the idea that Sherinian’s contribution to progressive music begins and ends with Falling into Infinity. The vocabulary is recognisably his, but the balance of responsibility is different. Here, the keyboards and drums can decide where the music goes without waiting for a vocal entrance.

Footnotes

  1. Derek Sherinian, 2003 comments on the making of Planet X, preserved in Through My Words. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  2. MusicBrainz, original Magna Carta CD, July 13, 1999, track program. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  3. Derek Sherinian interview, October 1999, on forming the band Planet X. ↩