EPs · 1995

A Change of Seasons

Tracklist

  1. A Change of Seasons23:09
    1. I.The Crimson Sunrise0:00
    2. II.Innocence3:50
    3. III.Carpe Diem6:54
    4. IV.The Darkest of Winters10:08
    5. V.Another World13:01
    6. VI.The Inevitable Summer16:59
    7. VII.The Crimson Sunset20:12
  2. Funeral for a Friend / Love Lies Bleeding (Elton John cover)10:48
  3. Perfect Strangers (Deep Purple cover)5:33
  4. The Rover / Achilles Last Stand / The Song Remains the Same (Led Zeppelin cover)7:28
  5. The Big Medley (medley of covers)10:32
    1. In the Flesh? (Pink Floyd)
    2. Carry On Wayward Son (Kansas)
    3. Bohemian Rhapsody (Queen)
    4. Lovin', Touchin', Squeezin' (Journey)
    5. Cruise Control (Dixie Dregs)
    6. Turn It On Again (Genesis)

Personnel

Dream Theater

Additional musicians and programming

  • David Rosenthal – Additional keyboard programming on the studio title track

Production

  • David Prater – Production and mixing of studio title track
  • Doug Oberkircher – Engineering and mixing of studio title track
  • Robert Siciliano – Assistant engineering of studio title track
  • Andrew Scarth – Engineering of Ronnie Scott's recordings
  • Vinnie Kowalski – Live recording engineering of Ronnie Scott's recordings
  • Ted Jensen – Mastering

Artwork and photography

  • Larry Freemantle – Art direction and sleeve design
  • Mike Portnoy – Cover concept
  • Joseph Cultice – Photography

A Change of Seasons is Dream Theater’s first EP, released by EastWest Records America on September 19, 1995. At just over 57 minutes, it’s longer than plenty of albums, including the band’s own debut. The EP description needs a little explanation: only the opening 23 minutes are newly recorded original music. The rest comes from a special show at Ronnie Scott’s Jazz Club in London, where the band put aside their own songs and clearly enjoyed playing music by other artists.12

The title track had been around since 1989, had been considered for Images and Words, and had built a reputation through bootlegs and correspondence between fans. Its finished recording introduced Derek Sherinian on a Dream Theater release and included some of Mike Portnoy’s most personal lyrics. So the EP did several things at once. It finally released a long-awaited song, introduced the new lineup and paid tribute to the musicians who’d inspired them. It also showed that fans organising through an early mailing list could have an effect.345

About the EP

The song that wouldn’t go away

The origins of A Change of Seasons predate the lineup that eventually recorded it. In 1989, Dream Theater were trying to work out what came next after When Dream and Day Unite. Charlie Dominici’s days as their singer were numbered, the Mechanic Records relationship was going nowhere particularly pleasant, and the four instrumentalists were already looking beyond the debut. One of the first substantial pieces they started developing was a long, multi-part composition built around ideas Mike Portnoy wanted to explore lyrically. John Petrucci later placed its beginnings in the same writing period as “Metropolis”.36

The ambition was hardly modest. Portnoy grew up worshipping bands that treated an entire side of vinyl as a perfectly reasonable length for a single composition. Yes had “Close to the Edge”, Genesis had “Supper’s Ready”, Rush had “2112”, and Pink Floyd had “Echoes”. Dream Theater were never likely to conclude that four minutes was plenty of time to make a point. What made this attempt different from simply copying their record collections was that Portnoy had a genuinely personal story to tell, and one that didn’t comfortably fit inside a conventional verse-chorus structure.37

The composition developed during the long search for a replacement singer. When James LaBrie auditioned in early 1991, he even sang an early version of it on a four-track recording. By the time the band signed to Atco and prepared Images and Words, A Change of Seasons was part of the proposed album. It had not been dreamed up retrospectively as some sort of missing companion piece. There were pre-production recordings, vocal ideas, arrangements and plans to record it properly.68

Then came the first day of the Images and Words sessions at Bear Tracks Studios in October 1991. The band arrived expecting to record the song and learned that the label had decided otherwise. The issue wasn’t whether Dream Theater could play it. They clearly could. The problem was that Atco was trying to establish a newly signed band with a new vocalist, and the executives were not particularly keen on putting a sprawling suite alongside an already lengthy collection of songs. Derek Oliver, the A&R executive involved, subsequently defended the decision as a necessary compromise for a group that still had to prove it could sell records. Portnoy, who had written the lyrics and was looking forward to finally getting them onto an album, was understandably furious.89

His frustration was more than the usual argument about whether a song should make the final running order. Portnoy had not contributed lyrics to the other songs on Images and Words because he expected his own piece to be there. When the song was dropped, so was the most direct personal statement he had intended to make on that record. Decades later he still remembered that decision as a painful one, even while acknowledging that a major label might have struggled to introduce a commercially unproven group with an album stretching towards 75 minutes.810

The band was given to understand that the song could be revisited later, potentially as a separate EP. In the record business, “later” can mean a very long wait. Images and Words came out, “Pull Me Under” became a surprise hit, and Dream Theater spent an enormous amount of time touring. A live album appeared. Then they recorded Awake, a record that already had more than enough freshly written material to fill its running time. Meanwhile, A Change of Seasons remained unfinished business.79

A legend built on two performances

During the Images and Words touring period, Dream Theater performed an early version of the piece in its entirety at the Limelight in New York in March 1993 and again in Germany the following month. The arrangement was not the final 1995 version, but it was more than enough to establish that the missing epic was real and, perhaps more importantly, that it was worth hearing. Audience recordings circulated among collectors, who began comparing what they had heard with the band members’ increasingly tantalising comments about the song.4911

It is worth remembering how information spread in those days. There was no YouTube upload from the front row a few minutes after the encore, no official social-media announcement, and certainly no streaming service offering an unreleased 20-minute progressive-metal composition at the click of a button. If you wanted to hear the piece, you needed to know someone who knew someone, find a tape or bootleg CD, and hope the recording wasn’t complete rubbish. That scarcity did the song’s reputation no harm at all.411

By 1995, the Ytsejam mailing list had given those scattered fans somewhere to organise. In February, fan Alex Reinelt encouraged subscribers to send written requests asking Elektra to let the band record the song. He gathered the petitions and forwarded them to manager Jim Pitulski, who in turn made sure the label saw them. At the end of March, Pitulski thanked the mailing-list members and confirmed that the campaign had helped secure approval. The contemporary press announcements described hundreds of letters reaching executives’ desks.412

The petition wasn’t the only reason the record finally happened. Portnoy and Pitulski had been pressing the case themselves, and the band had been talking about a separate release for years. But it would be wrong to dismiss the fans’ contribution as a bit of decorative publicity. Here was a community organised largely through email, lobbying a major record company to release a song nearly six times the length of a typical radio single. And it worked. The fans’ success still feels worthwhile all these years later.4512

Not the same song they wrote in 1989

Getting permission to record it didn’t mean dragging the old master tape out of a cupboard. There wasn’t a finished album master sitting there waiting for release. The band went back to the composition and reworked it extensively. Portnoy revised lyrics that he no longer felt represented him accurately, LaBrie reshaped vocal melodies, instrumental passages and arrangements were changed, and Sherinian brought his own personality to material originally written with Kevin Moore. By the time they were finished, the track ran for 23:09.356

This was especially significant for Sherinian. Replacing Kevin Moore during the Awake tour was one thing; playing complicated music that already existed was effectively his job description. Helping reshape a major new recording gave him an opportunity to become part of the band’s creative machinery. In a contemporary German interview, Portnoy credited him with contributing material to the beginning and end of the revised suite. Sherinian, for his part, joked in the Japanese fan-club interview that the most important thing he contributed was attitude. There was probably some truth in that, too.67

Petrucci’s sound had changed since the original writing period as well. The 1995 studio version employed his seven-string guitar, giving some of the heaviest passages a weight the earlier configuration couldn’t quite deliver. But the piece never abandons the more melodic, keyboard-rich side of the band. The contrast is central to how it works. The music moves from reflective passages to enormous riffs, through complicated instrumental exchanges and back to something intimate, usually just before it looks as though it has made up its mind which kind of song it wants to be.1013

Portnoy also revealed that the group briefly considered recording two entirely new compositions to accompany the epic. They had already written one substantial new piece with Sherinian, reportedly around 12 minutes long. Another plan was to include previously released non-album material, such as “Eve” and “To Live Forever”. Eventually they decided the new song deserved to be saved for a proper studio album, while the older B-sides wouldn’t introduce the new lineup in quite the way they wanted. The solution was sitting on tape from an unusual London concert earlier that year.57

Back to Bear Tracks, and back to David Prater

On May 18, 1995, Dream Theater entered Bear Tracks Studios in Suffern, New York, to record the definitive version. The timing was squeezed into a brief break in the Waking Up the World tour. James LaBrie recalled that the band spent roughly two weeks recording and mixing, treating the long composition as several distinct pieces that had to be worked through carefully rather than as an uninterrupted live performance.614

The label approved it on one condition: David Prater had to produce the track. Given their history, that was unlikely to please Portnoy. Prater had produced Images and Words, with its clear sound and undeniable success. His working relationship with the band on those sessions had been much less positive. Portnoy disliked the processed drum sound. Kevin Moore had also clashed with him. If Dream Theater had been allowed to choose their ideal reunion, a return to Prater’s control room probably wouldn’t have featured on the list.9

Derek Oliver regarded Prater as the man most likely to reproduce the sound and commercial impact of Images and Words, particularly after Awake had failed to deliver another “Pull Me Under”. Portnoy recalled agreeing to work with him only after Oliver insisted that no drum triggering would be used. Prater remembered receiving a similarly blunt warning from the label. Whatever anyone’s private feelings, the reunion went ahead, with engineer Doug Oberkircher back in the studio as well.915

Portnoy later said, somewhat surprisingly, that they got along better this time. Sherinian also remembered the producer as efficient and musically useful. The serious trouble instead developed around the vocals. LaBrie and Prater had sharply different ideas about the best recording method, the argument escalated, and their accounts of what happened remained contradictory when Rich Wilson interviewed them for Lifting Shadows. Prater accused the singer of being unprepared and difficult; LaBrie described a producer whose treatment of the band was needlessly antagonistic. Neither account should be treated as a neutral transcript of the room. What is clear is that the sessions became unpleasant enough for the singer and producer to clash openly.9

There was even an argument about a line in Portnoy’s lyrics. An originally intended profanity was replaced with the word “sympathy” after objections surfaced during the recording. Portnoy subsequently regarded the fuss as overblown, while LaBrie said he was uncomfortable attaching that particular language to the band’s recorded music. The original lyric, the objections and the revision all form part of the song’s recording history, rather than evidence of a mysterious alternate version that was ever commercially released.9

One happier disagreement concerned Petrucci’s guitar solo. Prater preferred an improvised take to the more painstakingly worked-out alternatives the guitarist wanted to try. The producer convinced him to keep it. Petrucci later admitted that the solo had been improvised, but still wasn’t particularly fond of it. Producers are paid to make decisions, and occasionally the musician spends the next few decades being reminded of one.9

Despite all the arguments, the result sounded polished and powerful. It also closed the book on the Dream Theater and Prater relationship. There would be no need to repeat that particular experiment when the group eventually began recording the follow-up to Awake.9

A night at Ronnie Scott’s

The other half of the release had been recorded before the title track’s studio sessions. On January 31, 1995, during the European leg of the Awake tour, Dream Theater played a special concert at Ronnie Scott’s Jazz Club in London, billed as Uncovered. The premise was gloriously simple: forget the usual Dream Theater repertoire and spend the evening playing music by the bands they loved.516

It was largely Portnoy’s idea, and not everybody needed convincing in quite the same way. The band had a huge amount of material to learn while already on tour. In the Japanese liner notes, Portnoy described using soundchecks on the January tour to practise cover after cover. They even worked Pink Floyd’s “In the Flesh?” into some regular shows to give it a test run. By the time they reached London, they were prepared to take on an entire evening of other people’s music. Whether this was a sensible use of scarce rehearsal time is another question. It was certainly a more entertaining one than another conventional promotional appearance.37

The full show went considerably further than the four live tracks eventually chosen for the EP. There were Rush, U2, Metallica, Marillion, The Beatles, Tori Amos, UK and Yes selections, with guest appearances by Steve Howe, Steve Hogarth, Steve Rothery and Barney Greenway of Napalm Death. The latter joined them for Metallica’s “Damage, Inc.”, taking the evening a long way from a typical jazz-club show.16

Those guests made the night a remarkable event in its own right, but the EP deliberately focused on the five Dream Theater members. Portnoy told MEAT magazine that several additional Ronnie Scott’s tracks had been mixed for possible B-sides, including Rush’s “Tears”, U2’s “Red Hill Mining Town” and the Greenway-assisted Metallica cover. He had wanted the guest performances saved for another occasion. As a result, the record offers a coherent, if wildly varied, selection from a much larger concert rather than pretending to document the complete evening.516

The four live tracks were recorded with the A&D mobile recording unit, with Andrew Scarth and Vinnie Kowalski credited for the live engineering. Crucially, these are not studio recreations of songs played that night. The pleasure of hearing the band attempt the material in front of an audience, sometimes with more enthusiasm than restraint, is a large part of their charm.1317

The music

A Change of Seasons

The title track was divided into seven movements, each representing another stage in a person’s life and another change in emotional weather. Portnoy described a character who begins as a child, discovers the world isn’t quite as straightforward as childhood promised, struggles with loss and disappointment, and ultimately grows old enough to pass on what he has learned. The seasons provide the organising metaphor, but the personal heart of the piece is very specific.618

On November 16, 1984, Portnoy attended a high-school class taught by Pat Lynch. The lesson dealt with carpe diem, the idea that life should be appreciated while it is here because it can change without warning. Lynch suggested that the students should tell their parents they loved them that evening. Portnoy did exactly that. His mother, Andrea Held Leone, was preparing to leave on a trip to Atlantic City; before going out with friends, he made a point of saying goodbye properly. Later that night she died in a plane crash. Years afterward, he still credited the teacher with giving him the chance to have that final moment with her.918

That experience is why reducing the song to “a story inspired by Dead Poets Society” misses the point. The film provided images, language and a dramatic framework that suited the message, but the event at the centre of it happened five years before the film was released. Portnoy also drew on The World According to Garp and Table for Five. The finished recording used dialogue from Dead Poets Society and Table for Five, while Garp remained a thematic influence rather than a source of samples. The distinction matters because the film references were vehicles for a personal memory, not substitutes for one.1918

I. The Crimson Sunrise

The opening doesn’t rush. Delicate guitar figures and a gradually expanding keyboard atmosphere establish the sense of looking out over a new landscape. There is a calmness here that makes the heavier material later in the song hit harder. Rather than announcing the arrival of a 23-minute epic with every instrument playing at full volume, the band allows the piece to assemble itself. You can hear the older progressive-rock influence, certainly, but the precision of the arrangement and the weight waiting just around the corner belong to Dream Theater.619

As an instrumental introduction, the section has the job of suggesting childhood before Portnoy’s narrator actually begins talking about it. Its title also establishes the sunrise-to-sunset framework that the final movement will close. The keyboard work is an early opportunity to hear Sherinian reinterpreting the song, rather than trying to impersonate Kevin Moore on a piece he had helped create years earlier.67

II. Innocence

LaBrie enters as the narrator recalls the confidence and freedom of youth. The melodies open up, and for a while the song sounds almost celebratory. That brightness matters. If the entire suite had been written in the same sombre tone as its central subject, it would have been a fairly exhausting listen. By beginning with something positive, Portnoy makes the eventual loss feel like an interruption to a real life rather than a dramatic effect invented for the song.618

The character is not Portnoy in every literal detail. This is still a fictionalised life story, one that stretches from childhood to old age. But the optimism belongs to the emotional logic of the piece: the things we assume will continue forever are often the very things we notice most painfully after they disappear.6

III. Carpe Diem

Here the song arrives at its core. The contrast between youthful certainty and mortality becomes explicit, and the message of seizing the day takes on the weight of Portnoy’s own experience. A phrase like carpe diem can easily sound like a harmless motivational slogan. In this case, it was something a teacher said to a teenager on the last day the teenager ever saw his mother. That makes it more substantial.918

The music reflects that transition without abruptly abandoning the opening themes. The shifting dynamics and instrumental interruptions allow the narrator’s recollections to develop into something more troubled. In the finished recording, LaBrie’s performance has the advantage of several years spent singing the band’s increasingly demanding material; this was not simply the 1991 vocal demo dusted off and tidied up.36

IV. The Darkest of Winters

One of the instrumental movements, “The Darkest of Winters” takes the emotional disturbance of the preceding section and turns it into a formidable piece of playing. The heavy riffs and complicated rhythmic figures don’t need a lyric to explain the title. This is the point at which the song feels most combative, with the guitar and keyboards trading momentum while the rhythm section keeps moving the ground underneath them.619

The studio recording also employs film dialogue tied to the loss of a mother, particularly material from Table for Five. That connection was important to Portnoy, who identified strongly with the film’s treatment of a family facing bereavement. The spoken extracts are another reason this is a difficult composition to understand purely as an exercise in technical showmanship. The astonishing instrumental performances are certainly there. They are not the whole story.920

V. Another World

The next vocal movement deals with grief, disillusionment and the uncomfortable business of growing older. The character has moved beyond childhood and is no longer able to take the world at face value. Musically, it is one of the track’s most dramatic passages, with sections of relative restraint giving way to much heavier bursts of frustration.619

It also contains one of the lyric changes that caused trouble during the 1995 sessions. The dispute over the original profanity and its replacement with “sympathy” might seem a fairly trivial bit of studio politics, but it says something about the competing ideas of what a Dream Theater record should be. Portnoy was writing from a deeply personal place; LaBrie and Prater had their own views about what the singer ought to deliver. In the end, the recorded text was a compromise, and the subject was still causing arguments long afterward.9

VI. The Inevitable Summer

After the emotional pressure of “Another World”, the music turns towards movement and release. This is the third instrumental section, with the kind of tightly coordinated guitar, keyboard, bass and drum interplay that had helped make Images and Words such a distinctive record. It is also one of the clearest examples of how thoroughly the band could develop musical ideas without a vocalist in the foreground.619

The piece doesn’t simply return to the optimism of the opening. It sounds more experienced, more complicated, with the emphasis on moving forward rather than pretending that everything has been put right. As musical storytelling goes, that feels entirely appropriate. Life doesn’t usually provide a neat solution to the things that happened in its darker passages.6

VII. The Crimson Sunset

The final movement brings the narrative full circle. The boy from the opening has become an old man, and now it is his turn to offer advice to the next generation. The sunrise of the first section becomes a sunset, not as a reversal but as the natural conclusion of a life lived through all those intervening seasons.618

This is where Portnoy’s message works best. The song isn’t arguing that loss can be avoided if people remember to appreciate one another. Quite the opposite. Loss is inevitable, time moves on whether anyone is ready or not, and the things that matter are worth acknowledging while they can still be acknowledged. The returning themes make the ending feel like the conclusion of the story, with a purpose beyond bringing the long piece to a stop.918

The 23 minutes contain enough riffs, changes and instrumental showpieces to satisfy anyone who enjoys Dream Theater for the more athletic side of the music. But the reason the composition has survived as something more than an impressive early epic is that it has a recognisable human reason to exist. It isn’t often that a track this complicated can ultimately be explained by something as simple as a young man being grateful he said goodbye to his mother.918

Funeral for a Friend / Love Lies Bleeding

The first Ronnie Scott’s recording on the EP comes from Elton John’s Goodbye Yellow Brick Road album, and is a reminder that Dream Theater’s musical upbringing extended rather further than Rush, Metallica and the usual progressive-metal reference points. Portnoy described the original as an overlooked favourite with an instrumental opening and a powerful rock song attached. That structure was a natural attraction for Dream Theater.3

They stay reasonably faithful to the composition’s broad shape. “Funeral for a Friend” offers a dramatic entrance, all atmosphere and anticipation, before “Love Lies Bleeding” breaks into a much more direct song. It is almost a miniature version of what makes the EP itself work: something expansive and elaborate giving way to the simple pleasure of a good melody, played by musicians who have no reason to prove they can handle difficult time signatures every thirty seconds.316

The choice was also a useful corrective to the idea that Dream Theater were a band whose members sat around listening exclusively to elaborate progressive-rock suites and heavy-metal riffs. They liked Elton John, Billy Joel, U2, The Beatles and plenty of other mainstream acts. It wasn’t always obvious from their own music, but the Ronnie Scott’s song choices made it clear.3

Perfect Strangers

Deep Purple were a fairly obvious influence for a band that loved both heavy riffs and prominent keyboards, but the version that ended up on the EP has a particularly nice backstory. Dream Theater had initially planned to perform “Child in Time”. The day before Ronnie Scott’s, however, they recorded “Perfect Strangers” with Iron Maiden singer Bruce Dickinson for his BBC Radio 1 programme. The rehearsal and recording worked so well that they changed their plans and played “Perfect Strangers” at the concert instead.3

The choice makes sense as soon as the opening riff lands. The song is heavy without being frantic, and its keyboard part is integral rather than decorative. Sherinian has plenty to do, the band can lean into the groove, and LaBrie gets a chance to sing something associated with one of rock’s great voices without turning the performance into an imitation contest.316

Portnoy later noted how important Deep Purple had been in demonstrating that keyboards could stand beside guitar as a genuine lead instrument in a hard-rock band. For Dream Theater, that was not a minor piece of musical history. It was one of the foundations of their own sound, and “Perfect Strangers” let them acknowledge it without the slightest need for an explanatory lecture from the stage.3

The Rover / Achilles Last Stand / The Song Remains the Same

If the Elton John selection reveals Dream Theater’s melodic side and Deep Purple supplies the heavy-rock ancestry, the Led Zeppelin medley is the band’s chance to indulge its enthusiasm for ambitious 1970s guitar music. Rather than settle for “Stairway to Heaven” or another obvious choice, they stitched together parts of three songs: “The Rover”, “Achilles Last Stand” and “The Song Remains the Same”.3

Portnoy explained that the sheer number of famous Zeppelin tracks made choosing one surprisingly difficult. Their solution was to pick material less likely to appear in a conventional tribute set. The band also admired Zeppelin’s willingness to let live performances stretch into long improvisational journeys, a fairly unmistakable connection with Dream Theater’s own approach to concerts.3

It isn’t a note-for-note historical reconstruction of Led Zeppelin. The recording sounds like Dream Theater playing Led Zeppelin, with Petrucci’s precision, Portnoy’s busy drumming and Sherinian’s keyboards making their presence felt. “Achilles Last Stand” in particular gives the rhythm section plenty to get its teeth into. In a 1995 interview Portnoy even recalled telling Jimmy Page about the proposed medley and getting a bemused reaction to their choice of that comparatively unusual track.7

The band had crossed paths with Jimmy Page and Robert Plant during festival appearances that summer, and their Japanese notes speak enthusiastically about seeing the reunited pair perform. The affection in the medley is genuine. So is the sense that, given the opportunity, Dream Theater were unlikely to leave a Zeppelin arrangement alone for long.35

The Big Medley

The final track is a ten-and-a-half-minute guided tour through the record collections of five men who had clearly spent an unhealthy amount of time listening to 1970s rock. Portnoy traced its origins to a June 1990 instrumental show on Long Island, when the singerless band performed as Ytse Jam and used a medley of favourites for the encore. The Ronnie Scott’s arrangement borrowed that idea and updated it for the LaBrie and Sherinian lineup.3

There are six fragments, each with its own little significance to the band’s history. The sequence makes musical sense as a piece of entertainment, but it is also something of an autobiographical sketch. These weren’t six songs picked randomly from a classic-rock compilation. They meant something to the musicians playing them.3

In the Flesh? (Pink Floyd)

They begin with the opening of Pink Floyd’s The Wall. Portnoy regarded the album as one of rock’s greatest, and using its opening as a way into the medley was both a tribute and a rather effective piece of stagecraft. The grandeur, the theatricality and the sense of an event about to begin are ideal ingredients for a Dream Theater performance.3

Carry On Wayward Son (Kansas)

Kansas gave them the chance to acknowledge another group whose progressive ideas were married to memorable songwriting. Portnoy thought the band was underappreciated relative to the bigger names in the genre, and this was a particularly enjoyable choice: a song with instrumental complexity, big harmonies and a chorus that doesn’t require an advanced degree in music theory to remember.3

Bohemian Rhapsody (Queen)

Queen’s best-known epic had already appeared in the band’s 1990 medley, before the success of Wayne’s World gave it another surge of mainstream popularity. This section isn’t there because the band suddenly discovered Freddie Mercury in the mid-1990s. Queen had been one of their formative influences for years, and “Bohemian Rhapsody” remains an excellent demonstration that elaborate arrangements and wildly theatrical musical ideas can also result in a popular song.3

Lovin’, Touchin’, Squeezin’ (Journey)

This one earns its place for a particularly personal reason. It was the first song Dream Theater played with James LaBrie when he auditioned for the band in January 1991. Steve Perry was an important influence on LaBrie’s singing, and the group’s reaction to the audition performance helped convince them they had finally found their vocalist. Slipping Journey into the medley was a neat nod to the moment the Images and Words lineup began to take shape.38

Cruise Control (Dixie Dregs)

The Dixie Dregs might be less familiar to casual listeners than the other bands in the medley, but their importance to Dream Theater is enormous. The mixture of rock, jazz, intricate arrangements and instrumental virtuosity was practically a permission slip for the young musicians to follow their own interests. Steve Morse, in particular, had been one of John Petrucci’s great guitar heroes. This section makes the medley sound like skilled musicians enjoying music they love, with little concern for its commercial potential.37

Turn It On Again (Genesis)

The medley closes with Genesis, but not with an obvious excerpt from “Supper’s Ready” or one of the group’s more elaborate Gabriel-era compositions. They chose the comparatively compact “Turn It On Again”, which Portnoy said worked as a strong ending. It was a sensible call. After ten minutes of hopping from one rock monument to another, a direct, energetic finish is precisely what’s needed. Dream Theater would have plenty of other opportunities to indulge their affection for the band’s longer pieces.3

The artwork and the release

The artwork carries the song’s idea of a complete life cycle onto the cover. A child appears in a winter landscape; an old man is shown by the sea, reinforcing the contrast between beginnings and endings, experience and innocence. The calendar detail refers to November 16, the date of Portnoy’s mother’s death. It is not an arbitrary decorative clue. Like the title track, the sleeve is built around a specific personal memory.9

Larry Freemantle, who had worked on the band’s previous releases, recalled that Portnoy arrived with a clear concept for what the images should show. Photographs of the models were taken and assembled into the finished sleeve. Portnoy is credited with the cover concept and Freemantle with art direction, with Joseph Cultice among the credited photographers. The imagery is less crowded than some of the band’s other sleeves, and appropriately so. This particular story hardly needs a pile of obscure objects scattered across the foreground to give people something to decode.917

The finished EP arrived on September 19, 1995. That date is supported by the original release chronology, Lifting Shadows, later official accounts and contemporary chart records; it corrects the September 10 date that appeared in the earlier discography metadata. It entered the US Billboard 200 at number 58 and also appeared on the UK albums chart. For an interim release led by a 23-minute composition and supported by live covers, that was a respectable result.1921

The label’s description of the record as an EP was deliberate. Dream Theater and EastWest did not want fans or retailers to mistake it for the full studio successor to Awake, even though its playing time was easily long enough to qualify as an album. In one sense it was an awkward bit of categorisation; in another, it was perfectly honest. There was one new studio composition and a live document of a special show. Calling it the band’s fourth studio album would have been substantially more misleading.15

Press reaction reflected that unusual format. Contemporary reviewers often admired the musicianship while acknowledging that this was hardly the ideal record to play someone who had never heard Dream Theater. A 23-minute progressive-metal suite followed by Elton John, Deep Purple, Led Zeppelin and a collection of six more covers is not a conventional recipe for generating the next radio hit. That wasn’t its job. Portnoy said quite openly in 1995 that the release was primarily for existing fans, and the band was happy to leave commercial expectations at the door for once.579

After the EP

The release helped establish Sherinian as more than the musician drafted in to play Kevin Moore’s parts on tour. It gave the group a studio recording they had actually shaped with him, along with a live document demonstrating how quickly he had fitted into their musical chemistry. At the same time, it allowed Dream Theater to put one of their longest-running creative frustrations behind them before turning to the next album.35

The new arrangement of A Change of Seasons also found a place in the live repertoire. The band introduced the revised version at European shows after recording it and played it on special dates in support of the EP, including three lengthy Japanese concerts in October 1995. As the catalogue grew, a 23-minute suite couldn’t fit every set list. Its occasional return still meant a great deal to the audience.522

A full performance later became part of the August 30, 2000 Roseland Ballroom concert documented on Live Scenes from New York and the special edition of Metropolis 2000. The song continued to return at selected shows over the following decades, eventually reaching a particularly satisfying anniversary moment in September 2025, when Dream Theater performed it in full again with Portnoy behind the kit for the first time since his return to the band. That 30th-anniversary revival placed the old suite alongside the much newer Parasomnia material, underlining how durable its musical language had become.2324

For the fans who petitioned a record company to release it, the EP was proof that a long-unavailable song could become a genuine part of the catalogue. For the musicians, it was the chance to finish work that had started before their breakthrough. And for Portnoy, it meant finally putting a memory that had shaped his life into the form he wanted. The live covers are a terrific bonus, full of personality and occasional cheerful excess, but they aren’t why the record matters so much.4518

In the wider Dream Theater catalogue, A Change of Seasons occupies a slightly odd position. It sits somewhere between a studio release and a live album, well beyond the traditional length of an EP. But it is a very good illustration of what made the band interesting in the first place. After six years of arguments about releasing a piece the industry didn’t know how to market, the five musicians finally recorded it. They filled the remaining half-hour with Elton John and Led Zeppelin covers. There are worse ways to spend 57 minutes.

Sources

The numbered references below point to the contemporary interviews, announcements and source documents used for the historical details. Later interviews are identified as retrospective accounts. Page numbers for Lifting Shadows refer to the book’s printed pagination. Assessments of the music’s character and performance are the author’s listening-based interpretation, not quotations or claims attributed to band members.

Footnotes

  1. Dream Theater, A Change of Seasons, official discography (release date given as September 19, 1995 in the body, EP designation, 57:30 duration, Derek Sherinian’s debut and the title track’s subject). The page has an inconsistent date in its display header; the textual history and independent release records agree on September 19. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  2. DT World, A Change of Seasons discography (original track sequence, lengths, streaming context and classifications; its September 10 date conflicts with the original release chronology). ↩

  3. Mike Portnoy and Dream Theater, A Change of Seasons Japanese liner notes, 1995 (extensive first-person explanation of the EP, the changes to the original track, the Uncovered concert, every cover song, Sherinian and the origins of the medley). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20 ↩21 ↩22 ↩23 ↩24

  4. DT World, “Dream Theater Treasure Hunt Walkthrough pt. 6”, December 2018 (history of the Ytsejam mailing list, Alex Reinelt’s February 1995 petition and Jim Pitulski’s March response). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6

  5. Carl Begai, “A Man for All Seasons: Mike Portnoy – A Dream Fulfilled”, MEAT 58, September 1995, extended interview (Portnoy on the release, fan petitions, rewriting, the rejected plans for other EP tracks, Ronnie Scott’s and the first concerts featuring the new version). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12

  6. “The Crimson Sunrise”, Images and Words fanzine 8, July 1995, band interview (Petrucci, Portnoy, LaBrie and Sherinian on the recording, rewriting, the seven-part narrative and Sherinian’s contribution). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16

  7. Andreas Schöwe, “Is It All Just Sheet Music?”, Metal Hammer Germany, October 1995, Mike Portnoy interview (the band’s musical influences, evolution of the song, new material written with Sherinian, Ronnie Scott’s and the recording’s explicitly fan-oriented purpose; translated from German). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9

  8. Rich Wilson, Lifting Shadows: The Authorized Biography of Dream Theater, pp. 80–82 and 95–98 (LaBrie’s audition, early four-track performance, Images and Words pre-production and the label’s decision to omit the song). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  9. Rich Wilson, Lifting Shadows: The Authorized Biography of Dream Theater, pp. 148–158 (1995 petition, recording, lyrics, disagreement with Prater, guitar solo, artwork, release, charts and critical response). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16 ↩17 ↩18 ↩19 ↩20

  10. Matt Wardlaw, “How Dream Theater Finally Rescued ‘A Change of Seasons’”, Ultimate Classic Rock, September 13, 2025 (Portnoy’s retrospective on the 1989 origin, label veto, personal significance and 1995 reworking with Sherinian and seven-string guitar). ↩ ↩2

  11. May 23, 1995, record-company press release, “Dream Theater Records A Change of Seasons” (documents the two earlier full live performances, fan campaign and studio start date). ↩ ↩2

  12. June 8, 1995, press release, “Dream Theater to Release ‘A Change of Seasons’” (the fan initiative, bootlegs, concert tapes and planned September release). ↩ ↩2

  13. MusicBrainz, A Change of Seasons release and performer credits (production, engineering, recording studio, vocals and keyboards); original-release credit transcription (detailed booklet credits). ↩ ↩2

  14. May 1995 recording announcement (May 18 arrival at Bear Tracks); July 1995 fanzine interview (LaBrie on the two-week sessions and separate instrument recording). ↩

  15. Rich Wilson, Lifting Shadows, pp. 150–155 (Oliver, Prater, Portnoy, LaBrie and Sherinian give sharply different accounts of the producer reunion). ↩

  16. DT World, “What was the Ronnie Scott’s gig?” (full January 31, 1995 set list, guest musicians and which tracks later appeared on other releases). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  17. A Change of Seasons, original CD production and artwork credits (the A&D Mobile Recording Unit, live and studio engineers, Larry Freemantle, photography, Portnoy’s design concept and mastering). ↩ ↩2

  18. DT World, “What is A Change of Seasons about?” (Mike Portnoy’s June 30, 2015 first-person account of Pat Lynch’s lesson, the last goodbye to his mother and the meaning of carpe diem); Rich Wilson, Lifting Shadows, pp. 149–151. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9

  19. DT World, seven-movement sequence and section timings, FAQ (Portnoy’s timings and official movement titles); official band discography. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  20. DT World, “Where did the quotes in A Change of Seasons come from?”, FAQ (Dead Poets Society and Table for Five dialogue); Rich Wilson, Lifting Shadows, p. 150 (Portnoy describes the personal importance of the films). ↩

  21. MusicBrainz, original 1995 A Change of Seasons European release (September 19, 1995 release event); ChartVault, Billboard 200 chart history (US peak number 58); Official Charts Company, UK chart history (UK peak number 88). ↩

  22. Portnoy, MEAT 58 interview, September 1995 (1995 European premieres); Portnoy, Red Sector A interview, December 1995 (the three Japanese concerts and the place of the song in the band’s live shows). ↩

  23. Dream Theater, Live Scenes from New York, official discography (August 30, 2000 Roseland show); Metropolis 2000 Special Edition listing (the complete suite as additional concert footage). ↩

  24. Dream Theater’s September 5, 2025 tour opener, Blabbermouth (the first complete performance with Portnoy since his 2023 return); 2026 James LaBrie interview, Rolling Stone Brasil, archived by Through My Words (the 30th-anniversary return and continuing live relevance). ↩