Dream Theater

Live At The Marquee East West 450 993 371-2

Issuing a live album just two studio releases into their career is a very suspect move. Why recycle material so quickly, particularly when the live versions are virtually identical to their studio counterparts? Dream Theater are an immensely talented band whose studio and concert performances are almost indistinguishable. Their fusion of metal and symphonic rock is not enhanced or modified in the live setting; DT are meticulous and exacting and display little of the rock 'n' roll spirit or take any real chances.

The songs, although complex, are executed with clinical precision; there's not even the odd bum note to add a little interest or originality to the performances. Even the audience response is muted, as they no doubt realise they could just as easily be sat at home listening to the same music in identical form on CD.

The structures and arrangements alternate the technical sophistication of Queensrÿche, Yes and ELP with the bludgeon riffola of Metallica, Megadeth and Annihilator. Although designated mini-album status, the six cuts clock in at a full 45 minutes and features three tracks apiece from their first two albums. A good introduction to the band, but somewhat redundant if you already own the studio material.

Rating: 3 out of 5 (worth borrowing)

—Ian Kenyon